
~/mythology/comparative-mythology
Witzel’s Origins of the World’s Mythologies Is Memetic Eve
Michael Witzel reconstructed one world storyline, invented once by one person and taken over on a large scale. Change the inventor’s sex and date, and it is Memetic Eve.
TL;DR
- In The Origins of the World’s Mythologies (2012), the Harvard Sanskritist Michael Witzel reconstructs one storyline that runs from creation to the end of the world, told from Iceland to Tierra del Fuego.
- His conclusion: “someone, about 40,000 years ago, had to come up with it first”, “it must have been a shaman”, and the idea “was taken over on a large scale” (p. 422).
- That is Memetic Eve: one person, one discovery about the human condition, spread by uptake from people to people.
- Witzel’s own oldest myths put a woman at the origin: in Melanesia, “a woman broke the taboo of not looking” while humans shed their skins like snakes, and death came (p. 364).
- His own Sahul chapter has the serpent High God cross into Australia over the Ice Age land bridge, about 26,000 to 8,000 years ago (pp. 295, 307).
- Change the inventor’s sex and date, and the rest of his architecture stands as built.
But someone, about 40,000 years ago, had to come up with it first. As it is closely related to the concepts of the Paleolithic hunt, the rebirth of animals, and shamanism, it must have been a shaman who did so. — E. J. Michael Witzel, The Origins of the World’s Mythologies (2012), p. 422
Witzel’s single inventor #
When I proposed Memetic Eve in 2024, I defined her as “the person to have the first sapient thought and manage to share that with others such that it became the foundation of human culture.” The post predicted that the world’s creation myths should be strikingly similar if that foundation spread recently, and it pointed to one book as proof that “a good case can be made that the world’s creation myths stem from a common root.” The book was Witzel’s.
Read cover to cover, the relation is closer than a citation. After more than 400 pages of comparison, Witzel arrives at a single inventor, a single idea and a single wave of uptake. He calls it “the genial stroke of the creator of Laurasian mythology” (p. 422). He is precise about what the creator saw, how the idea travelled and what it carried. Then he names a man and puts him 40,000 years ago.
Witzel’s The Origins of the World’s Mythologies is Memetic Eve with the inventor’s sex and date changed. His own evidence supports both changes.
What does Witzel’s Origins of the World’s Mythologies argue? #
Witzel finds one plot across Eurasia, the Americas and Polynesia, which he calls Laurasian. The world emerges from chaos, darkness or the primordial waters. Generations of gods follow, then the slaying of the dragon, the first humans, their offence, the flood and the final destruction. He reconstructs it the way a linguist reconstructs a protolanguage, motif by motif and in order. “Laurasian mythology is our first novel,” he writes, “and the Pan-Gaean motifs are the oldest tales of humankind” (p. 6).
Below the novel lie older strata. Gondwana mythology survives in sub-Saharan Africa, the Andaman Islands, New Guinea and Australia. It has no cosmogony: “its focus is the origin of humans” (p. 339). Below that is a Pan-Gaean layer, which he believes left Africa with the first emigrants about 65,000 years ago. Its motifs include “death and shed skin … Milky Way as serpent, Rainbow Snake” (p. 368).
What the creator grasped, Witzel says, was “a fairly simple idea, the correlation of the ’life’ of humans and the universe” (p. 422). The Laurasian storyline “is a metaphor of the human condition”, told “from the ‘birth’ of the universe until its ‘death’ (and its eventual rebirth)” (p. 422). To make that correlation, a mind has to hold its own life as an object, from birth to death and hoped-for rebirth, and project that shape onto the cosmos. Witzel’s founding idea is the mind turning back on itself.
Witzel and Memetic Eve, point by point #
| Witzel, Origins (2012) | Memetic Eve and the Eve Theory | |
|---|---|---|
| How many inventors | “someone … had to come up with it first” (p. 422) | “the person to have the first sapient thought” |
| What was found | the human life cycle mapped onto the universe, “a metaphor of the human condition” (p. 422) | “I am”, or “I am a moral agent who will one day die” |
| How it spread | “so obvious and fascinating” that it was “taken over on a large scale” (p. 422) | “it’s easier to be taught an idea than to discover an idea” |
| The package | creation, first humans, “evil and death”, the dragon, the flood (pp. 78–79) | creation myth, the Fall, death, the serpent, initiation |
| Its subject | Gondwana’s “focus is the origin of humans” (p. 339) | the origin of humans as self-aware beings |
| The serpent | shed skin, Rainbow Snake, snake High God in the oldest layers (pp. 307, 368) | the Snake Cult of Consciousness |
| Inventor | “it must have been a shaman” (p. 422), carried “by male Paleolithic shamans” (p. 237) | Eve, the first woman who knew |
| Date | “about 40,000 years ago” (p. 422); Gondwana “c. 65 kya” (p. 387) | within the last 50,000 years; the teaching spread about 15,000 years ago |
The first six rows are the same model. One storyline, invented once. Witzel’s whole method depends on it: a plot with a fixed order of episodes cannot be produced twice by accident, any more than two languages arrive independently at the same irregular verbs.
Spread by uptake. Witzel’s official mechanism is descent. Early in the book he writes that the mythology “has been spread not by diffusion but above all by the constant advance of humans” (p. 35). At the origin he describes the opposite: the concept was taken over because it was “fascinating” to “a large section of the contemporaneous Eurasian descendants of the Out of Africa migrants” (p. 422). Living peoples adopted a new idea. He also grants that myths “can ‘jump’ the language barriers and move from one culture to the next” (p. 195), and that “individual motifs and even small myth cycles can drift and travel” (p. 280). That is diffusion, and it is the mechanism of Memetic Eve.
One package. Witzel’s storyline carries the episodes that the Eve Theory reads as the memory of the event. “With the first humans, evil and death enter into the world as well” (p. 78). The hero slays the dragon, from Indra’s three-headed reptile to Susa-no-o’s eight-headed Yamata-no-Orochi (p. 78), and the flood follows the hubris of the first people (p. 79): first humans, a serpent, a transgression, knowledge and death.
The serpent in Witzel’s oldest layers #
Witzel’s best serpent material comes from the region where his strata meet, western New Guinea and northern Australia. Three passages stand out.
The Dani, central highlands of western New Guinea, Indonesia. Witzel’s Melanesian creation has old people who “could shed their skin, like snakes, and enter a new life”. He goes on: “This idea is strongly present in western New Guinea as well, for example, with the highland Dani, for whom the faculty of rebirth was lost through a mangled message delivered by the snake Kalije and the Sibine bird (the hornbill)” (p. 307, from Kamma 1978). The serpent held renewal and carried the message of it, and humanity lost renewal when the snake’s words came out wrong. Speech, the serpent and death arrive together.
Biak and Numfor, Cenderawasih (Geelvink) Bay, Papua, Indonesia. “The snake is regarded ‘as prototype of the primordial chaos’ that led to the dualism of the dead and the living—note that it is sometimes said to have two heads and a double name—and it is closely related to initiation.” In another Biak myth, “the killed snake becomes the ancestor of humans” (p. 306). Witzel adds that this “reminds much of some Australian concepts, and perhaps not without good reasons, as Papua myths and genes influenced parts of northern Australia during the last Ice Age.”
The northern Kimberley, Western Australia. Here “the incipient shaman is swallowed by the Rainbow Snake or scum from the snake’s pool is inserted (as snake egg) into his navel and grows inside him” (n. 118, p. 566). In the fuller account the master “puts the shrunken candidate (at the size of a newborn) in his pouch”, “rides on the Rainbow Snake upward to the sky”, and kills him. The novice’s organs are replaced: “He inserts small rainbow snakes or a lizard of great power. … The adept returns to life insane; this ends after he has painted himself, a few days later” (p. 388, after Eliade and Elkin). In the north and northwest the Rainbow Snake is an “All-Mother” who “carries her children inside her” (p. 324).
Witzel infers his inventor from “the rebirth of animals, and shamanism”. In his own best Australian evidence, the shaman is a man the serpent has swallowed and rebuilt, his old self shrunk to a newborn and returned insane until he paints himself again. The shaman is what the serpent rite makes.
The first change: a woman, not a shaman #
Witzel’s case for a man is short. The idea concerns the hunt and shamanism, so “it must have been a shaman” (p. 422). Myths were “propagated and transmitted by male Paleolithic shamans”, because “males usually are more mobile than females” (p. 237). That explains how myths travel, and leaves open who thought of them first. His own notes add that among Australian “clever men”, “some women also act as shamans” (p. 566).
Against that stands his own data. Melanesia, from Papua New Guinea to Vanuatu: “The emergence of death, thus, is another important Pan-Gaean motif. As the Melanesian version puts it, humans at first did not die, they just changed their skins (like snakes do). However, a woman broke the taboo of not looking at this process” (p. 364).1 Witzel ranks this motif Pan-Gaean, in his oldest layer. In it, immortality belongs to the snake’s way of renewal, and the act that ends it is a woman’s look. It is the same act that is forbidden at the bullroarer from New Guinea to Brazil, where a woman who sees it dies.
He states the pattern himself. “Very frequently death is paradoxically attributed to the giver of life—a primordial woman—and to her curiosity (Bible, but importantly, also in non-Laurasian areas such as Melanesia).” He then turns it on the tellers: “This should tell us something about the mind-set of the (male) originators of this mytheme. We must not forget that all too often we only have the male version of mythology” (p. 78). In Gondwana myth, too, death comes from “some misdeed or mistake, often one committed by a woman” (p. 364).
Witzel finds the same story among the forest foragers at Maseda in the Ituri forest of the Democratic Republic of the Congo. There, “a pregnant woman craved a certain fruit of the Tahu tree that the creator had forbidden to be eaten. As a result, humans now have to die” (p. 315). His note says that “the myth echoes the biblical motif of the punishment of Eve”, and that Schebesta stressed that the people “had no knowledge of biblical matters” (n. 298–299, p. 549).
The Eve Theory reads this as a memory told from Adam’s side. The first woman did something with her eyes and her curiosity, and that changed what it means to be human. The men who kept the tale cast her knowledge as the cause of death. EToC gives the reason she would be first: girls reach mirror self-recognition and pronoun use earlier, and the first sapient idea “likely had to do with Theory of Mind or language, which women have an advantage on” (Memetic Eve, n. 2).
Witzel also notices that the women’s stories survive inside the men’s. “Some of their stories have been retained even in the male-dominated hunters’ and shamans’ tales of Laurasian mythology. … We therefore have to distinguish (grand)father’s tales from (grand)mother’s tales” (p. 376). In the same paragraph he sets aside the peoples who “‘recall’ a mythological original dominance of women”, naming the Fuegians of Tierra del Fuego, Argentina and Chile, as “incidental evidence” (p. 376). His own flood myth from the same people ends: “ever since that time, women have been ruled by men” (p. 178).
The Fuegians were explicit about what came before. The Selk’nam told Anne Chapman that the women had once run the Hain, the masked lodge, and played its spirits to terrorise the men. When the men found out, Sun roared, “Strike down the women!”, and of the female sex “only the innocent little girls and babies remained” (Chapman 1982, p. 70). The Yamana elder Masemikens told Gusinde, “We men long ago took the kina away from the women.” The Bullroarer Atlas’s Mother Right maps 116 peoples who say the same of their secret instrument or mask: the women had it first, and the men took it. A shaman’s rite that men say they took from women, often killing them, does not point to a male inventor.
The second change: the date #
Witzel’s absolute dates come from genetics, which he uses as a clock. The Pan-Gaean layer left Africa about 65,000 years ago, Gondwana serpent power “must go back to Gondwana times, c. 65 kya” (p. 387), and Laurasian mythology is “probably around c. 40,000 BCE” (p. 65). In each case he attaches a body of myth to a migration and gives the myth the migration’s date. (The method is taken apart in Out of Africa, by Assumption.) The layers give an order of events. The dates are borrowed from population history.
His own evidence points to a later clock in three ways.
The layering. A sequence of strata is also what successive waves of diffusion leave behind. Keep Witzel’s order, Pan-Gaean, then Gondwana, then Laurasian, and read each as a later stage of the same teaching. The sequence survives; only the borrowed dates go.
The land bridge. Witzel dates one serpent precisely, and the date is late. The snake High God of western Melanesia spread “eastward into the Solomons and also southward into northern Australia, when a land bridge existed during the last Ice Age” (p. 307). The dragon or giant snake of New Guinea “seems to have spread from New Guinea eastward toward the Solomons and, during the last Ice Age, over the land bridge to northern and central Australia” (n. 418, p. 495). The window is “the Last Glacial Maximum, when Australia was connected with New Guinea from c. 26,000 until 10,000–7,000 years ago” (p. 295), with Papuan influence lasting “until c. 8000 BP” (p. 249). That is Witzel’s own date for the serpent’s arrival in Australia, inside the Eve Theory’s window, and it fits the rock art: the first Rainbow Serpents of Arnhem Land are dated to about 9,400 to 6,000 years ago.
The speed. An idea that is “so obvious and fascinating” that it is “taken over on a large scale” moves as fast as people meet, which is much faster than populations replace one another. Memetic Eve rests on the same observation: when someone “cobbled together the first suitable creation myth, it would have spread like wildfire.” Fast uptake makes a late date easy and an early one hard: a whole novel with a fixed order of episodes, kept intact across Eurasia and the Americas for 40,000 years, must survive more than twice as many generations of retelling as it would in 15,000.
The date change is smaller than it looks. Memetic Eve’s outer bound is “the last 50,000 years”, and Witzel’s 40,000 falls inside it. The Eve Theory’s specific date comes from Snake Cult Two: methods for teaching the “I” “spread worldwide about 15,000 years ago with the Snake Cult”. Witzel’s inventor is already in the right epoch. His serpent crossed the bridge at the right time.
Change two variables #
Set Witzel’s conclusion beside the Memetic Eve post and the architecture is the same. One person discovered something about the human condition: that a life runs from birth to death and might be renewed, and that the self who lives it can be seen whole. Neighbours took it over. It travelled as a package of first humans, transgression, death, serpent and flood, and it is why the world’s myths can be reconstructed as one.
Witzel built that model from the evidence. He then gave the inventor a man’s sex and a date taken from genetics. His own sources say otherwise on both points. The oldest death myth he has turns on a woman who looked. The rite he uses to define the shaman is one in which the Rainbow Snake swallows a man and makes him new. The serpent he can date crossed into Australia at the end of the Ice Age. Make the shaman Eve, let the bridge set the clock, and The Origins of the World’s Mythologies reads as a history of her discovery.
Related posts #
- Memetic Eve Solves the Sapient Paradox
- Eve Theory of Consciousness v3
- The Snake Cult of Consciousness Two
- Out of Africa, by Assumption
- The First Rainbow Serpents
Sources #
- Witzel, E. J. Michael. The Origins of the World’s Mythologies. Oxford University Press, 2012. Cited pp. 6, 35, 65, 78–79, 178, 195, 237, 249, 280, 295, 306–307, 315, 324, 339, 364, 368, 376, 387–388, 422, 495, 549, 566.
- Cutler, Andrew. “Memetic Eve Solves the Sapient Paradox.” Vectors of Mind, June 26, 2024.
- Cutler, Andrew. “Eve Theory of Consciousness v3.” Vectors of Mind.
- Cutler, Andrew. “The Snake Cult of Consciousness Two.” Vectors of Mind.
- Chapman, Anne. Drama and Power in a Hunting Society: The Selk’nam of Tierra del Fuego. Cambridge University Press, 1982, p. 70.
- Gusinde, Martin. Die Feuerland-Indianer, vol. 2, Die Yamana. Mödling, 1937, pp. 1343–45.
- Kamma, F. C. Religious Texts of the Oral Tradition from Western New-Guinea (Irian Jaya), Part B. Brill, 1978.
- Elkin, A. P. Aboriginal Men of High Degree. Sydney, 1945.
- Taçon, Paul S. C., et al. “Extraordinary back-to-back human and animal figures in the art of western Arnhem Land, Australia: one of the world’s largest assemblages.” Cambridge Archaeological Journal 32(4) (2022).
- Bullroarer Atlas. “Mother Right: The Myth of Matriarchy and the Men’s Secret Instruments.”
The archive.org scan of Witzel crops the top line of most pages, so the sentence after “this process,” on p. 365 is lost. Page numbers here are printed pages (scan leaf minus 20), checked at nine legible folios. Witzel’s source for the Melanesian skin-change is Panoff’s survey of Oceanic myth (1967); the Dani text is in Kamma 1978, p. 122; the Kimberley initiation comes through Eliade from A. P. Elkin’s Aboriginal Men of High Degree (1945). ↩︎