TL;DR
- There is hard evidence of contact between Greeks and Buddhists (Alexander’s campaign, Pyrrho in India, Aśoka’s edicts naming Greek kings and issuing one in Greek at Kandahar, the Milindapañha, and Pāli chronicles naming Yona [Greek] monks). These show transmission channels existed, not that any given doctrine was borrowed.1 Strabo, Geography 15; Arrian, Anabasis 7; Aśoka edicts; Greek Edict of Kandahar; Milindapañha; Mahāvaṃsa, (https://www.gutenberg.org/files/46976/46976-h/46976-h.htm), (https://www.ancient-buddhist-texts.net/Texts-and-Translations/Ashoka-edicts/King-Ashoka.htm), (https://www.britishmuseum.org/collection/object/W_1896-0908-6), (https://archive.org/details/questionsofkingm00rhyuuoft), (https://archive.org/details/mahavamsagreatch00geigrich)
- Pyrrhonism and early Buddhism share striking vocabulary and therapeutic aims; some scholars argue influence from Buddhism on Pyrrho, but this remains contested and not provable from extant texts. Beckwith 2015; Kuzminski 2008; SEP “Ancient Skepticism”, (https://www.routledge.com/Pyrrhonism-How-the-Ancient-Greeks-Reinvented-Buddhism/Kuzminski/p/book/9780739124019), (https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/skepticism-ancient/)
- Stoicism/Epicureanism vs Buddhism show programmatic convergences (ataraxia/equanimity, therapy of desire), plausibly via convergence plus shared Hellenistic–Śramaṇa “askēsis” culture, not necessarily direct borrowing. McEvilley 2002
- Many similarities predate the Hellenistic moment and likely reflect Near Eastern and Indo-Iranian networks feeding both Greeks and Indians. M. L. West 1971; Burkert 1992; Bronkhorst 2007/2011, (https://monoskop.org/images/7/7e/Burkert_Walter_The_Orientalizing_Revolution_Near_Eastern_Influence_on_Greek_Culture_in_the_Early_Archaic_Age.pdf), (https://global.oup.com/academic/product/greater-magadha-9780199203055)
- Bottom line: connections are real and multiple; unidirectional derivation claims are overconfident. The weight of evidence supports contact and some influence, with third-source contributions and independent parallel development.
“Conquest by Dharma has been won here… and also among the Greeks (Yonas).”
— Major Rock Edict 13, Aśoka (3rd c. BCE), tr. N. A. Nikam & R. McKeon, via Ancient Buddhist Texts
What counts as a “connection”?#
By “connection” we mean historically evidenced channels (people, texts, inscriptions, institutions), not just similarity. Evidence falls into: (1) textual attestations of encounters; (2) bilingual/Greek inscriptions in Buddhist regions; (3) narratives of Greco-Buddhist dialogue; (4) prosopography of Greek Buddhists; and (5) conceptual correspondences argued by comparativists. Each is graded below with sources and caveats.
1) Contact in the historical record (4th–1st c. BCE)#
- Alexander’s expedition (327–325 BCE) brought Greeks to Taxila and the Punjab. Greek authors report gymnosophists (naked sages), including Dandamis and Kalyana/Calanus, who dialogued with or rebuffed Alexander. Arrian, Anabasis 7.1–3; Strabo, Geography 15.1, (https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Strabo/15A1*.html), (https://www.livius.org/sources/content/arrian/anabasis/alexander-and-the-indian-sages/)
- Pyrrho of Elis (c. 360–270 BCE) travelled with Alexander to India, per Diogenes Laertius, and is said to have shaped his philosophy after discussions with Indian sages. Influence is plausible but not provable from primary testimony alone. Diog. Laert. 9; SEP, (https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/skepticism-ancient/)
- Aśoka’s edicts (mid-3rd c. BCE) mention Greek polities and kings (Antiochus, Ptolemy, et al.), implying missionary outreach across Hellenistic networks; one edict at Kandahar is in Greek, targeted to a Greek audience. Major Rock Edict 13; Greek Edict of Kandahar (BM), (https://www.britishmuseum.org/collection/object/W_1896-0908-6)
- “Yona” (Greek) monks appear in Pāli chronicles: Mahāvaṃsa names Dhammarakkhita the Yona preaching at Aparānta, and Mahādhammarakkhita travelling from Alasanda (Alexandria) with 30,000 monks for a Sri Lankan stūpa dedication—evidence of Greek participation in Buddhist orders. Mahāvaṃsa 12, 29 (Geiger tr.)
- The Milindapañha (1st c. BCE/CE) stages dialogues between monk Nāgasena and Indo-Greek king Menander (Milinda); Plutarch mentions cities dividing Menander’s ashes, a Buddhist-coded honor. Milindapañha (Rhys Davids tr.), Plutarch, Precepts of Statecraft
2) Archaeology, empire, and roads#
- Achaemenid satrapies extended to Gandhāra/Hindūš; Perso-Iranian networks already linked Anatolia–Mesopotamia–Iran–NW India before Alexander. Encyclopædia Iranica entries “Gandhāra”; “Hindush”, (https://iranicaonline.org/articles/india-iii)
- After Alexander, Greco-Bactrian/Indo-Greek states sat atop early Silk-Road arteries, facilitating Hellenic-Indic exchanges (ideas along with art: Greco-Buddhist Gandhāran idioms). General synthesis in The Greek Experience of India
Table 1. Chronology of well-attested Greco–Buddhist contacts#
Date (BCE/CE) | Event / Evidence | What it shows |
---|---|---|
327–325 BCE | Alexander in NW India; reports of gymnosophists (Dandamis, Calanus) in Greek sources (Arrian, Strabo) | Direct philosophical encounters; Greek curiosity toward Indian askēsis. (Arrian; Strabo) |
c. 325 BCE | Pyrrho travels east with Alexander; later teaches epochē/ataraxia (DL 9) | Plausible Buddhist contact shaping Pyrrhonism; evidence is suggestive, not clinching. (DL; SEP) |
c. 260s BCE | Aśoka’s Major Rock Edict 13 names Greek kings; Greek edict at Kandahar | Buddhist proclamation aimed at Greek audiences; trans-imperial moral mission. (Aśoka; BM) |
3rd–2nd c. BCE | Yona monks in Mahāvaṃsa (Dhammarakkhita; Mahādhammarakkhita) | Greeks inside the Saṅgha; bidirectional religious movement. (Geiger tr.) |
2nd–1st c. BCE/CE | Milindapañha (Nāgasena–Menander); Plutarch on Menander’s ashes | Formal Greco-Buddhist philosophical dialogue; Buddhist commemoration of a Greek king. (Rhys Davids; Plutarch) |
Doctrines: parallels, influence claims, and critiques
Pyrrhonism & early Buddhism#
The classic case is the claim that Pyrrho imported a Buddhist-like therapy. Modern reconstructions hinge on Aristocles’ report (via Eusebius) of Pyrrho’s three marks of things: adiaphora (undifferentiated), astathmēta (unstable), anepikrita (undecidable)—which some align with anicca/duḥkha/anattā. Beckwith 2015; Kuzminski 2008, (https://www.routledge.com/Pyrrhonism-How-the-Ancient-Greeks-Reinvented-Buddhism/Kuzminski/p/book/9780739124019). Skeptics note the thin textual bridge and late testimonia; the therapeutic telos (ataraxia) is shared across Greek schools. SEP
Pyrrhonian term (Aristocles) | Claimed Buddhist analogue | Caution |
---|---|---|
adiaphora (no fixed nature) | anattā (no self) | “Nature” vs “self” is not one-to-one; textual dependence unproven. [Beckwith; critiques in reviews] |
astathmēta (unstable) | anicca (impermanence) | Genuine overlap possible via common phenomenology. |
anepikrita (undecidable) | avyākata (undetermined), noble silence | Strongest resemblance, but also matches Greek skepticism broadly. [SEP] |
Assessment. Afaict, influence is plausible given Pyrrho’s travels and the Kandahar Greek edict milieu; yet direct textual dependence is unproven and debated. Balanced treatments: McEvilley (comparativist synthesis), and critiques by Indologists reviewing Beckwith. (McEvilley 2002)
Stoicism/Epicureanism & Buddhism#
Shared aims: passion-therapy, training of attention, moderation, cosmopolitan ethics. But metaphysics/ontology diverge (Stoic logos and corporealism; Buddhist anattā/dependent origination). The safest read: partial convergence within a trans-Eurasian askēsis culture rather than one-way borrowing. [McEvilley 2002; general overviews in SEP entries]
Third sources: Near Eastern and Indo-Iranian feeders#
Before Alexander, Greek philosophy already shows Near Eastern imprints.
- Orientalizing Greece. Early Greek cosmology, mythic motifs, and techniques (divination, number) display Mesopotamian and Levantine influence. Burkert, The Orientalizing Revolution
- Greek philosophy & the Orient. M. L. West mapped close parallels between Presocratic notions and Near Eastern materials, arguing for channels of transmission. West, Early Greek Philosophy and the Orient
- Indo-Iranian frames. The Achaemenid system knit Iran–Gandhāra–Anatolia, while śramaṇa movements in Greater Magadha formed the soil of early Buddhism/Jainism, somewhat outside Brahmanical orthodoxy. Iranica “Gandhāra/Hindūš”, Bronkhorst, Greater Magadha; Buddhism in the Shadow of Brahmanism, (https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/johannes-bronkhorst-buddhism-in-the-shadow-of-brahmanism.pdf)
Takeaway. Similarities between Greek and Buddhist ideas need not imply direct borrowing: both could be drawing from older Near Eastern/Indo-Iranian repertoires, then refined through local philosophical projects.
What we can and cannot say#
- We can say Greeks and Buddhists met, talked, and sometimes shared communities (e.g., Yona monks). Mahāvaṃsa; Milindapañha, (https://archive.org/details/questionsofkingm00rhyuuoft)
- We can say certain conceptual toolkits overlap (skeptical suspension; desire-therapy; equanimity). [SEP; McEvilley]
- We cannot presently prove a specific text-to-text derivation for any core Buddhist doctrine from Greek sources, nor vice-versa—except that Buddhist public communications addressed Greeks directly (Aśoka’s Greek edict) and Greek rulers/monks participated in Buddhism. (Aśoka; Kandahar), (https://www.britishmuseum.org/collection/object/W_1896-0908-6)
- We should expect mutual influence at the margins, third-source feeding, and parallel invention—not a single ancestor for “the same doctrine.”
FAQ#
Q1. Did Buddhism “cause” Greek Skepticism?
A. Unproven. Pyrrho’s Indian travel plus close programmatic parallels make influence plausible, but evidence is circumstantial; Pyrrhonism also fits longer Greek skeptical traditions. [Diog. Laert.; SEP; Beckwith; Kuzminski]
Q2. Was there a Greek Buddhist king?
A. Menander (Milinda) is the best case: dialogued with Nāgasena and received a Buddhist-coded funeral per Plutarch. Proof of engagement, not that “Greek states became Buddhist.” [Milindapañha; Plutarch]
Q3. Are Stoicism and Buddhism “the same”?
A. No. They share therapeutic aims and practices but diverge on metaphysics (Stoic logos vs Buddhist no-self/emptiness). Convergence and intercultural askēsis likely explain most overlap. [McEvilley 2002]
Q4. What’s the strongest single artifact tying Greeks to Buddhism?
A. The Greek Edict of Aśoka from Kandahar—a Buddhist moral proclamation composed in Greek for a Greek audience. (BM catalog)
Footnotes#
Sources#
Primary / Classical
Arrian. Anabasis of Alexander. Open translation: E. J. Chinnock (1884), Project Gutenberg, “Book VII.” “Anabasis of Alexander — Book VII”.
Strabo. Geography 15.1. Public-domain Loeb text via LacusCurtius. “Strabo, Geography, Book XV, ch. 1”.
Diogenes Laertius. Lives of Eminent Philosophers (esp. 9 on Pyrrho). Series index at Loeb. “Diogenes Laertius — Lives”.
Plutarch. Moralia: Precepts of Statecraft. Loeb preview with Menander passage. “Precepts of Statecraft”.
The Edicts of King Aśoka. Consolidated translations (incl. Major Rock Edict 13). Ancient Buddhist Texts edition.
Greek Edict of Kandahar (ca. 3rd c. BCE). British Museum catalog entry. BM Object W.1896,0908.6.
Milindapañha (The Questions of King Milinda). Tr. T. W. Rhys Davids (1890). Internet Archive PDF.
Mahāvaṃsa (The Great Chronicle of Ceylon). Tr. Wilhelm Geiger. Internet Archive PDF.
Comparative & Historical Studies
Beckwith, Christopher I. Greek Buddha: Pyrrho’s Encounter with Early Buddhism in Central Asia. Princeton, 2015.
Kuzminski, Adrian. Pyrrhonism: How the Ancient Greeks Reinvented Buddhism. Rowman & Littlefield, 2008. Publisher page.
McEvilley, Thomas. The Shape of Ancient Thought: Comparative Studies in Greek and Indian Philosophies. Allworth, 2002.
Bronkhorst, Johannes. Greater Magadha: Studies in the Culture of Early India. OUP, 2007. Publisher page.
Bronkhorst, Johannes. Buddhism in the Shadow of Brahmanism. Brill, 2011 (OA PDF).
Burkert, Walter. The Orientalizing Revolution. Harvard, 1992.
West, M. L. Early Greek Philosophy and the Orient. Clarendon, 1971.
Stoneman, Richard. “Naked Philosophers: The Brahmans in the Alexander Historians and the Alexander Romance.” Journal of Hellenic Studies 115 (1995): 99–114. JSTOR/academic access; overview at Livius.
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. “Ancient Skepticism.” (ongoing).
Contextual / Empire
Encyclopædia Iranica. “Gandhāra.” and “Hindūš (Indus).”
(Survey) The Greek Experience of India: From Alexander to the Indo-Greeks. Princeton UP, 2012. access link
This report scopes “Buddhist philosophy” to early sutta/śramaṇa frames and subsequent Gandhāran/Indo-Greek interactions; later Mahāyāna/Neoplatonic contacts are real but outside the core evidence treated here. ↩︎